What Animals Were in the Manger?

The birth of Jesus of Nazareth, a pivotal event in history, is often depicted with a manger scene because of how Luke tells the story in his Gospel.

This iconic representation showcases a humble setting, emphasizing the simplicity and modesty of the birthplace.

Central to this depiction is the manger, a place where animals were traditionally fed.

Over time, various animals have been artistically included in this scene, each adding a layer of symbolism and depth to the story.

This article seeks to explore the animals that might have been present in the manger and the historical context behind these choices.

What does the New Testament say about animals in the manger? See below

What Does the Bible Say about Animals in the Manger?

The Bible does not specifically list the animals present at Jesus’ birth in the manger.

The popular imagery of oxen, donkeys, and sheep surrounding the newborn Jesus primarily stems from tradition and artistic depictions over the centuries.

The Gospel of Luke mentions that Jesus was laid in a manger because there was no room in the inn, indicating a setting where animals were kept.

However, the exact types of animals present are not detailed in the biblical accounts.

Historical Context of Mangers

Mangers, during the time of Jesus of Nazareth’s birth, were common structures found in the Middle Eastern regions.

They were primarily used as feeding troughs for livestock and were typically made of stone or wood.

Located either within a household’s courtyard, adjacent to homes, or in caves, these troughs were essential for families who depended on agriculture and livestock for their livelihood.

The climate and geography of the region played a role in the design and placement of mangers.

With varying temperatures, it was crucial to provide shelter for animals, protecting them from extreme weather conditions.

As a result, many mangers were situated inside caves or stable-like structures, offering natural insulation.

Given the agricultural nature of societies in this era, it was not uncommon for families to share spaces with their animals, especially during the colder months.

This cohabitation allowed for easier care and feeding of the livestock, ensuring their well-being.

The presence of a manger in such settings indicates the importance of animals in daily life and the practicality of having them close by.

manger Bible
What animals does tradition associate with the manger? See below

Animals Traditionally Associated with the Manger

When picturing the scene of Jesus of Nazareth’s birth, many envision a serene setting filled with various animals surrounding the manger.

While the specific animals aren’t detailed in historical texts, several have become traditionally associated with the nativity scene based on cultural interpretations, art, and literature.

Sheep: Given the presence of shepherds who were said to have visited the newborn, it’s logical to assume that sheep were nearby. Sheep were also a primary livestock animal in the region.

Cows or Oxen: These animals are often depicted in nativity scenes, possibly due to their common presence in stables and their significance in agricultural societies.

Donkeys: Mary and Joseph’s journey to Bethlehem might have included a donkey for transport, especially considering the long distance and Mary’s advanced pregnancy.

Camels: While camels are not directly mentioned in the context of the manger, they are often associated with the Magi or Wise Men, who are believed to have visited Jesus sometime after his birth.

Goats: Common livestock in the Middle East, goats were essential for milk and cheese production. Their inclusion in artistic representations of the manger scene reflects their ubiquity in daily life.

Doves or Pigeons: These birds were common in the region and held significance in various ceremonies and traditions. Their gentle nature might also symbolize peace, a theme often associated with the nativity story.

Over time, these animals have become emblematic of the manger scene, representing the humble and rustic circumstances of Jesus’s birth.

Jesus Christ born manger
Where does the tradition of animals originate? See below

Sources of Animal Imagery in the Manger

The imagery of animals surrounding the manger in the story of Jesus of Nazareth’s birth has been a lasting one, but where did these images originate?

While the exact details aren’t explicitly outlined in historical records, several sources have contributed to the popular depictions we recognize today.

Artistic Representations: Over the centuries, artists have been instrumental in shaping the visual narrative of the manger scene.

Various cultures’ paintings, sculptures, and stained glass windows have often included animals to emphasize the humble setting of the birth.

Literature and Hymns: Written works, including hymns and poems, have played a role in popularizing the presence of animals at the manger.

For instance, the well-known hymn “Away in a Manger” mentions cattle, reinforcing the idea of their presence.

Cultural Interpretations: Different cultures have added their own interpretations and traditions to the manger story.

For some, specific animals hold particular symbolic meanings or are more commonly found in their region, leading to their inclusion in local nativity scenes.

Agricultural Practices: Understanding the agricultural practices of the time provides context for the types of animals that might have been present.

Stables and mangers were primarily for livestock, so it’s reasonable to assume such animals would be nearby.

Apocryphal Texts: Some non-canonical texts and writings from the early Christian era offer additional details and narratives about the birth of Jesus.

While not considered official records, they have influenced popular beliefs and traditions.

Nativity Plays: Theatrical representations, especially those performed during festive seasons, have solidified the idea of animals at the manger.

These plays often incorporate livestock to create a realistic and immersive experience for the audience.

In summary, while there isn’t a definitive list of animals present at the manger, a combination of art, literature, cultural traditions, and historical context has shaped the imagery we associate with the scene today.

Symbolism of Animals in the Manger

The presence of animals in the manger scene, where Jesus is said to have been born, carries significant symbolic weight.

Often depicted in art and literature, these animals are not just mere background characters but convey deeper meanings and reflections of the event’s significance.

Ox and Donkey: Traditionally, an ox and a donkey are among the most commonly depicted animals in manger scenes. The ox, known for its strength and service, can symbolize patience and hard work.

Often used for transportation, the donkey might represent humility and the journeys undertaken in the narratives leading up to the birth.

Sheep: Sheep are frequently shown, reflecting the shepherds who were among the first to visit the newborn. Symbolically, sheep are often associated with innocence and gentleness.

Camels: While not directly in the manger, camels are sometimes included in the wider nativity scene, representing the Magi or Wise Men’s long journey from the East. They signify endurance and the far-reaching significance of the birth.

Doves: Doves, when included, can symbolize peace and purity. Their presence might hint at the messages of peace and reconciliation often associated with the story.

Cattle: Representing the actual function of a stable, cattle also emphasize the humble circumstances of the birth. Their calm demeanor can be seen as a reflection of the tranquility and sanctity of the event.

Horses: Less commonly depicted, but when present, horses might symbolize journey, movement, and the broader changes that the birth would set into motion in the world.

Through their symbolic meanings, the animals in the manger scene add layers of interpretation to the event.

They connect the story to universal themes of humility, peace, and dedication, making it resonate with audiences across different cultures and eras.

Modern Representations

Over time, the depiction of the manger scene has evolved, adapting to contemporary tastes, cultures, and artistic expressions.

Modern representations of the manger and its associated animals often reflect a blend of tradition and innovation.

Diverse Animals: Today, it’s not uncommon to find a wider variety of animals included in manger scenes, from cats and dogs to more exotic creatures.

These additions often reflect local fauna or artistic creativity, making the scene more relatable to different audiences.

Artistic Mediums: The manger scene has been reimagined in various forms, from digital art and animation to public installations made from recycled materials.

These modern mediums allow for fresh interpretations and accessibility to younger generations.

Cultural Adaptations: In many parts of the world, the manger scene is adapted to reflect local customs and settings.

For instance, in some African depictions, the stable might resemble a traditional hut, while in certain Asian portrayals, local wildlife might be present.

Simplified Scenes: Minimalist art and design trends have influenced some modern manger scenes.

These often feature abstract or stylized figures and animals, focusing on form and color over detailed realism.

Interactive Experiences: With the rise of technology, interactive nativity scenes have emerged, allowing viewers to engage with the story.

Virtual reality, for example, can transport users to a reimagined manger setting, offering a unique, immersive experience.

Eco-friendly Themes: Environmental consciousness has also influenced modern manger depictions.

Some artists emphasize sustainability by using natural or recycled materials, while others incorporate animals affected by climate change to draw attention to current global challenges.

Modern representations of the manger scene demonstrate its enduring appeal and adaptability.

By blending time-honored elements with contemporary influences, artists, and creators ensure that the story remains relevant and resonant for today’s audiences.

Daniel Isaiah Joseph

Daniel's seminary degree is in Exegetical Theology. He was a pastor for 10 years. As a professor, he has taught Bible and theology courses at two Christian universities. Please see his About page for details.

Related Questions

error: This content is copyrighted.